Dentures and Deep Dish? What to Eat (and Avoid) with New Dentures in Chicago

Getting new dentures is a big step toward restoring your smile, confidence, and ability to enjoy food again. But if you’re in Chicago, you may be wondering: Can I still eat my favorite deep-dish pizza?

While your taste buds are ready to dive into a slice from Lou Malnati’s or Giordano’s, your dentures might need a little warm-up first. In this guide, we’ll help you navigate eating in the Windy City with new dentures—starting with what’s on the plate.

What You Can Eat with New Dentures (Yes, Even in Chicago!)

When you first get dentures, your gums and jaw need time to adjust. Early on, stick to soft, easy-to-chew foods. Here are some Chicago-friendly meals that won’t stress your smile:

Denture-Friendly Chicago Eats:

Italian beef (dipped, sliced thin): Just skip the crusty roll at first.
Chicago-style hot dogs (no poppy seed bun): Chop it up to make chewing easier.
Polish sausage (well-cooked and sliced): Soft and flavorful.
Deep dish pizza (deconstructed): You can enjoy the soft, cheesy filling with a fork before tackling that thick crust.
Soup: Think chicken noodle, tortilla (skip the crunch chips at first), or cream of mushroom.
While adjusting, mashed potatoes, scrambled eggs, and soft veggies are great choices.

What to Avoid (for Now)

Certain textures and temperatures can dislodge, irritate, or even damage your new dentures—especially in the first few weeks.

Foods to Skip in the Beginning:

Crusty or chewy bread: Think bagels, baguettes, and even some pizza crusts.
Caramel, taffy, or chewy candies
Steak or tough meats: These can be famously hard to chew, even for experienced denture wearers.
Nuts and seeds: Small pieces can sneak under your dentures and cause irritation.
Popcorn: Those kernels are not your friend—yet!
Hot beverages: Give your mouth time to adjust to temperatures to avoid burns.

Dentures in the Real Chicago World

Chicago is full of delicious distractions. Whether you’re heading to Portillo’s, trying to enjoy a summer BBQ, or sampling tamales from the 26th Street vendors, the key is patience and preparation.

Tips for Dining Out with Dentures:

Cut food into small pieces.
Chew slowly and on both sides of your mouth.
Bring denture adhesive for extra security if needed.
Don’t be afraid to ask for a knife and fork—even for pizza.

The Good News: It Gets Easier

With time, your mouth will adjust, and your denture-wearing confidence will grow. Many of our Chicago patients tell us they’re back to enjoying their favorite foods (yes—even deep dish!) after a few weeks of practice.

Have Questions About Eating with Dentures?

At ABC Dental Chicago, we’ve helped hundreds of patients in Logan Square, Belmont Cragin, and across Chicago transition to dentures successfully—and comfortably. If you have questions about sore spots, adhesives, or long-term denture care, our team is here to help.

Book a consultation today, and we’ll make sure nothing stands between you and your next deep dish slice.

Our team serves Chicago neighborhoods like Logan Square, Belmont Cragin, and Avondale — and we’re known for our gentle, caring approach, especially with nervous patients.

Our team is here to answer any questions you have. We offer FREE SECOND OPINIONS. We’re open nights and weekends. Book Your Appointment with one of our top Chicago dentists: Schedule online or Call us at 773-481-2200